The Churches of Lathander and Cyric have announced a holy war
The situation is complex. Neither party is without fault, with the Cyricists actively seeking to create discord within the Kingdom and threatening the populace by withdrawing their services, and the Lathanderites fueling the conflict through their heresy.
While we made numerous attempts to apprehend the Cyricists prior to the proclamation of war, I recognise that these failed both due to the lack of tactical approach and limited evidence to support our actions. Failure to take quick and sufficient action means the situation has escalated to one in which Crown Guard individuals have less control given the religious nature of this conflict, the complex political interactions, the size of the opposing forces, as well as our own limited resources.
The background papers have further information about events, if required.
I propose we maintain a position of public neutrality and mininal interference in the interim
The Crown Guard, as an extension of the Crown itself, has several options to consider in deciding their immediate role in this conflict:
Remain publicly neutral, use minimal force to restore order and security (status quo, recommended in interim)
Remain publicly neutral, use maximum force to end the conflict and stabilise the region
Publicly support the House of the Morning, and by extension, the Bishopric of Eveningstar
Publicly support the Church of Cyric.
The options outlined here are the product of an initial assessment will evolve as the conflict progresses, with any decision reviewed as required.
Option
Implementation
Rationale
Risks
Mitigation
Option 1
Publicly neutral ie no support for either faction, maintain open communication with both factions, establish perimeter to contain conflict, regulate rules of conflict, protect non-combatants and private property, use force where risk of escalation beyond perimeter
Religious conflict vs our role as secular organisation, duty to maintain order and security regardless of faith, complex situation requiring more strategic approach, limited resources to use more force
Opposing factions gain political power and territory, benefits Cyricists who support this position, lose opportunity for CG to gain prestige, lose relationship with both parties, reputational risk with general populace
Use as interim measure (not long-term position, see other options), deal with proxies (eg mercenaries) to gain prestige
Option 2
Publicly neutral, use Kingdom forces to quickly override both factions and restore regional stability
Gain prestige, restore reputation, reduce opponent's political power, gain power in territories
Limited resources and tactical expertise, interfering in religious matters risks fallout with faithful
Use as final resort when factions have weakened each other
Option 3
Publicly announce support for House of the Morning, lend resources to faction, withhold resources from Cyricists, publicly condemn Cyricists and punish them for misdeeds and failure of duty
Eveningstar is established sub-state, expect our support, good allies generally more trustworthy than evil ones, popular among people
Propogate heresy, lost first conflict, gives Bishopric greater power
Negotiate for greater power in Bishopric
Option 4
Publicly announce support for Church of Cyric, lend resources to faction, withhold resources from Lathanderites, publicly condemn Lathanderites and punish them for heresies
Responsible for rites of death, relied upon by populace, won first conflict, demonstrated power
Untrustworthy, seek to undermine Crown's authority, linked to suspicious characters, likely linked to Tilverton's ambitions
Negotiate for greater power (what, where? Still unclear)
Sub-options include covertly supporting one faction over the other (eg with information, funding) despite public neutrality, or lending aid depending on circumstances and offers given in turn.
Option 1 is most suitable for our current circumstances, and my own capabilities. I do not have the capacity alone to carry out this action, and therefore seek the following support from superiors:
Re-station Guards (Crown and/or Militia) to the western and northern outskirts, to manage any outspill of conflict. A group of 4-5 is recommended, including 2 scouts
Expediate requests for bounties or funding where this supports our role (eg, rewarding contractors)
Provide advice on strategic and political issues as they arise, and respond quickly where I escalate issues.
I will also aim to achieve the following on my own:
Maintain open communication with factions and assert our right to passage through conflict areas without interference
Support or contract adventurers and mercenaries to investigate and gather intel, deal with issues on the periphery, and protect citizens and private property
Promote permanent recruitment to the Guard, including among the plebs.
I also suggest that any of the Crown Guard who wish to join either side are choosing faith over duty to kingdom, and must remove their uniform.
//I don't know how audacious this is but thought I would give it a shot given my limited playtime.